There’s something deeply sensual and satisfying about cooking seafood. The sizzle of scallops in a pan. The brininess of just-shucked oysters. That flaky, melt-in-your-mouth snapper. But unless you live at the dock (and if you do, can I come over?), shopping for fresh seafood can feel… intimidating.

Between opaque labels (“previously frozen,” “Atlantic,” “farm-raised”), slippery textures, and eye-watering price tags, it’s easy to walk away with fish that’s meh at best—or worse, smells like it’s halfway to being compost.

So here’s your definitive guide—equal parts culinary school know-how and fishmonger flirting—to help you shop for seafood like a boss. Whether you're hitting up a grocery store, fish market, or chatting up a guy named Sal who sells scallops out the back of his truck, these tips will steer you right.

1. Trust Your Nose First (Not the Price Tag)

Here’s the golden rule: fresh seafood should smell like the ocean, not like a fish tank that hasn’t been cleaned since Obama’s first term.

If you catch even a whiff of sourness, ammonia, or anything pungent, walk away. Fish should have a clean, salty smell—like a breeze off the water, not something that makes your eyes water.

Pro tip: If it smells fishy, it’s old. Period.

2. Eyes, Flesh, and Gills: A Fishy Face Check

If you're buying whole fish (which often gives you better freshness for the price), give it a full-on facial once-over.

• Eyes: Should be clear and bulging, like they just saw the group chat drama. Cloudy or sunken eyes are a no-go.
• Flesh: Should bounce back when pressed. If your finger leaves a dent, that fish is tired.
• Gills: Bright red or pink = good. Brown or slimy = hard pass.

This isn’t the time to be shy. You have permission to get up close and personal. Consider it self-care, but for your dinner.

3. Touch It (If They’ll Let You)

Fresh fish and shellfish should feel firm, moist, and resilient—not slimy or sticky. If you’re buying fillets and they’re mushy or flaking apart before you cook them, that’s not just fish—it’s fishy.

Shellfish specifics:

• Shrimp: Should be firm and translucent. If they’re pre-peeled, they lose freshness quickly, so buy shell-on when you can.
• Scallops: Should be dry, not sitting in a milky liquid. That liquid is often a phosphate bath (pass).
• Clams/Mussels: They should be tightly closed. If they're open, give 'em a tap. If they don’t close, they’re dead. And not in the delicious way.

4. Know the Lingo: Fresh vs. Previously Frozen

Don’t let “fresh” signage fool you. In many grocery stores, “fresh” fish was actually frozen and then thawed for display.

That’s not always a bad thing! Flash-frozen fish can be higher quality than “fresh” fish that’s been sitting on ice for four days. Just be informed.

Ask:

“Was this fish previously frozen?”
If they hesitate to answer, assume yes.

5. Ask What Came in That Day (And What Didn’t)

The best seafood counter employees know their stock, and the best ones won’t lie to you. Strike up a conversation. Ask:

• “What’s the freshest thing here today?”
• “What would you take home for dinner tonight?”

You’ll learn quickly what just came off the truck… and what’s been hanging out longer than your toddler at bedtime.

6. Don’t Sleep on the Freezer Section (Really)

Listen—freezer burn is real, but the freezer aisle can be your secret weapon.

Look for:

• Individually quick frozen (IQF) fillets
• Wild-caught shrimp with the shell and tail on
• U.S.-sourced or sustainably certified options

Hot tip: Vacuum-sealed frozen fish is often fresher than the stuff on ice. Buy a few packs to stash in the freezer and thank me on a random Tuesday night when you don’t feel like going to the store.

7. Use Your Hands, Use Your Voice, Use Your Common Sense

If something seems…off, it probably is. Seafood isn’t cheap, and you deserve quality. Trust your senses—smell, sight, touch—and don’t be afraid to walk away or ask questions. You’re not being annoying. You’re being smart.

And let’s be honest—most of the men in your life are winging it anyway. You may as well show up at the fish counter with the confidence of someone who watches Chef’s Table and also knows where to find the best smoked paprika.

Bonus Chef Tips:

• Bring a cooler or insulated bag to keep fish cold on the drive home.
• Cook or freeze seafood within 24 hours of buying it.
• Acidic marinades (like lemon juice or vinegar) “cook” seafood fast—great for ceviche, but not for long marinating.

‍

‍Final Thoughts: ‍

Shopping for seafood doesn’t have to feel like a test you didn’t study for. The more you do it, the more confident you’ll become. Like anything in the kitchen, trust your instincts, ask questions, and don’t be afraid to say no. You’ve got this.

‍

‍

‍

‍

‍

‍